Personal Democracy Forum – HotSoup Sneak Peek

HotSoup Sneak Peek
By Micah L. Sifry, 10/19/2006 - 5:42am

Want to get a look at the innards of HotSoup--the soon-to-be-launched new entry in the social-networking sweepstakes? While the site's homepage will turn you away, just go to any of these links--HotIssues, About, Press, or Contacts and you're in. They've also left open links to several of their "Opinion Drivers"--famous people from the worlds of politics, business, religion, and popular culture who presumably are going to blog brilliantly for the site, which aims to focus heavily on politics. Looking forward to the deep thoughts of cyclist Lance Armstrong, lobbyist Ed Gillespie, veterans activist Bobby Muller, or "political diva" (that's her online handle on the site) Donna Brazile? You can check them out too.

It's obviously not fair to judge a site before it's launched, and we here at PDF certainly welcome more experiments in merging professional and amateur voices, top-down and bottom-up social networks. But it is intriguing to ponder what Ron Fournier and crew are up to. The site clearly aims to draw an audience by tapping prominent writers from across the political spectrum (something none of the major political celebrity blogging sites like HuffingtonPost or PajamasMedia currently do). And readers appear to be slated a larger and simpler role in visibly rating posts with an "agree/disagree" tool that will show how every contributor stands with the community--though it seems those ratings may take the place of raw comments (which might discomfit some of the celebs). One odd choice--bulletin boards for "Issue Loop" discussions. I can't remember the last time I waded through a forum on a bulletin board!

It's also hard to see where the social networking features come in. It looks like HotSoup will allow users to create personal profiles and to nominate non-celebrities to be "hot issues panelists." But at least from the pages that they left exposed, it's not clear that average folks will find HotSoup are more compelling place to bat around their political views than, say, a lively community blog.

What do you think?

Technorati Tags: HotSoup, HuffingtonPost, PajamasMedia, Ron Fournier,

Big Media | Citizens Media | Startups
Micah L. Sifry's blog | email this page |

delicious | digg

digg |

technorati

no DNC

RNC is a user on hotsoup, and has one of those special stars for opinion leaders. Where's the DNC?

By gina at Thu, 10/19/2006 - 10:50 | email this page

and one more thing

Ark Gov Mike Huckabee is on there. Where are our presidential hopefuls?

By gina at Thu, 10/19/2006 - 10:53 | email this page

Ed Gillespie and Income Disparity

Micah - The more I think about the site the more it occurs to me it's supposed to be farce. Ed Gillespie is a real issue being ignored by the politicians and the press. I'm sorry.

You read that correctly, income disparity is the issue Gillespie feels is being ignored by Washington, Wall Street and other institutions. It pains me that someone like Ed's never in his been in a position to be able raise the issue of income disparity. It's complete farce.

By kombiz at Thu, 10/19/2006 - 12:23 | email this page

Technology and the Internet are changing democracy in America. Personal Democracy Forum is a hub for the exciting conversation underway between political professionals, technologists, and anyone else invigorated by the remarkable potential of technology to engage citizens in the democratic process.